
The Gossip (ca. 1920) by William Penhallow Henderson
The morality of gossip is complicated: it is rarely considered always or never morally problematic; most philosophers consider it wrong under certain conditions, but for differing reasons.
Gossip: Moral Objections and Defences
Gossip can be objected to on Kantian grounds, for failing to treat others with respect and concern, even when the gossip is truthful, and the gossipee would disclose the information themselves. It is not the same kind of wrong as breaching someone’s trust by disclosing information they wish to keep confidential. However, as Cécile Fabre argues, “Accurate and disclosable gossip … has more in common with its deceitful and breach-of-trust cousins than might be supposed.”
Other objections to gossip are harm-based, virtue-based, exclusion-based, or religious (e.g. Buddhists object to gossip both because of the intentions behind it and the harm it can cause). Ethical frameworks can also help us when deciding which forms of gossip are morally acceptable. Under utilitarian considerations, Emrys Westacott argues that “talk which is not contrary to C’s wishes, or which is likely to bring about some tangible further good” is morally permissible. Westacott notes that utilitarianism can help highlight the “many positive aspects of gossip”.
The social and psychological benefits of gossip can lead us to view many instances of it as beneficial overall. For example, ‘positive gossip’ (praise about an absent peer) can enhance someone’s reputation and motivate others to improve themselves or their lives, whereas ‘negative gossip’ can teach people which behaviours are toxic or socially unacceptable, without having to make the mistake firsthand.
However, the moral complexity of gossip means that it can also be morally mixed; it can be a ‘burdened virtue’, as Mark Alfano and Brian Robinson suggest. This is because in environments of systemic oppression and power imbalances, informal truth-telling becomes a necessary tool for survival and resistance. Yet it still carries moral risks: gossip can be false, distorted by biases, or based on incomplete information. Thus, the gossiper carries the heavy burden of potentially ruining an innocent person’s reputation. It also lacks a positive name – there is no term for ‘gossiping well’, and even those who gossip to protect others may be stigmatised and viewed with suspicion. In addition, gossip exists because ideal conditions do not; if the world were fair or safe, people would not need to gossip to seek justice or safety.
Similarly, the philosopher Karen Adkins contends that gossip often functions as a moral good, enabling those with less power to protect one another when formal justice systems fail to do so. It is a non-ideal but necessary solution.
Nameless Gossip
Can we retain the myriad benefits of gossip while avoiding its moral issues by anonymising those we talk about? Many of the moral risks of gossip involve the reputation of the absent person who’s being discussed, which may have downstream negative effects on their relationships, work, and social life more generally. By idly talking about someone absent in an unconstrained way, we can reach (or lead others to) conclusions about this person that are false, incomplete, biased, or unfair. The absent person has no chance – in that moment – to defend themselves, explain, clarify, or add context. And as some philosophers argue, even when gossip is truthful, it may nonetheless be unjustified.
By anonymising those we talk about, it may seem we can redeem gossip. After all, if we don’t name those we’re talking about, how can we damage their reputation? I try to keep people anonymous in conversations if I think offering a real-life example of a relationship or situation is relevant and helpful, and I don’t want to share private details about someone’s life that they might feel uncomfortable with me sharing.
Nevertheless, anonymised gossip is not morally untainted; in certain contexts, it can still disrespect people’s privacy and cause harm. Anonymised gossip faces practical issues: to ensure it’s morally permissible, we must be tactful about what personal information we reveal, so as not to accidentally identify the person. It requires a certain level of care and vigilance. In this way, the practical (or skilful) side of anonymised gossip is connected to its moral side.
Moreover, anonymity can also undermine gossip’s role as a moral good: by keeping names out of important conversations, we may prevent justice from being served; those abusing their privilege and power may get away with it and keep doing so.
How Anonymity Retains the Benefits of Gossip
Nameless gossip can still allow us to enjoy the many benefits of gossip, including advice, feedback, support with forgiving someone or moving on, or getting something off our chests that’s weighing us down. When we keep gossip anonymous, we can still express and maintain social and moral standards of what’s acceptable, and learn lessons about the consequences of certain mistakes.
It may be objected that anonymised gossip is not truly gossip since it doesn’t involve an identifiable person – and all gossip concerns people whose identity is known (by at least one of the people involved in the conversation). However, this is more of a semantic point; what’s pertinent is that what we value about gossip can be retained through anonymity. So, for all practical purposes, anonymised gossip can (at least in many contexts) function like conventional gossip.
However, as mentioned above, anonymised gossip is less likely to hold powerful, predatory people to account, unless someone is easily identifiable from the details shared about them, even if their name hasn’t been disclosed. As an everyday moral issue, the ethics of gossip may be better captured by moral particularism: whether it is permissible or impermissible depends on the context and particularities of the situation. Conventional gossip may be justified – even virtuous, or a ‘burdened virtue’ – when it seeks justice for a serious wrong committed by someone in a protected position and identification is necessary to that aim. When the benefits don’t depend on identification, anonymised gossip would be preferable. In this way, we can gossip ethically, which involves nameless gossip in most situations, without sacrificing its benefits.
The Difficulty in Keeping Gossip Anonymous
It’s worth reiterating that keeping gossip truly anonymous can be a challenge. Without being cautious, someone may be able to identify who’s being talked about. This risk of anonymised gossip burdens the gossiper, and, on an exclusion-based account, someone may be uncomfortable with someone walking this conversational tightrope, in which one shared detail may be all it takes for someone to guess who’s being talked about.
Nameless gossip in general may encourage listeners to try and guess the gossipee. If they want to find out the name, they may ask “Is it [X]?” and even if the gossiper refuses to answer, listeners may latch onto any vocal or body language changes as an answer. In other words, nameless gossip doesn’t avoid the problem of listeners coming away with an idea of who was being talked about, which may affect their impression of this person. And so, as with named gossip, reputational damage may result.
We can see how nameless gossip is not inherently any better than named gossip in a scene from Curb Your Enthusiasm, where Larry’s therapist is talking about a former client:
Dr Thurgood: I had a client. He was quite an illustrious, well-known director. I don’t want to reveal who he was, but he did direct Star Wars. And he enjoyed in his repertoire of things that he liked to see prostitutes. Now in that particular situation, if he were to hire a prostitute, let’s say for an hour, which was normal for him…
Larry: You might as well call him George Lucas. I mean, that’s who directed “Star Wars.”
Dr Thurgood: Well, I would never say that. I would never say that. You just told me who it was. I merely alluded to the fact that he was a well-known director. Now, one of the things that he needed to complete his work…
Larry: Everybody knows who directed Star Wars.
Dr Thurgood: Not everyone is in show business, Larry.
For anonymous gossip to be truly anonymous, one has to avoid revealing any obviously identifiable information. This is also contextual. Say you’ve previously gossiped about someone, using identifiable information, then you decide it’s best to keep them anonymous; if you talk about the situation again with the same people, but omit their name, profession, how they look, etc., and just refer to them as ‘this friend’ or ‘someone’, it will still sound like the same person.
When anonymous gossip involves someone listeners also know, or know well, the risks of identifying them are higher. Simply describing their behaviour or personality, or the relationship between the gossiper and gossipee, may give someone a strong clue as to who’s being talked about. So, leaving out as many non-essential personal details as possible is best, which can also be a balancing act, as some of these details may clarify the situation and better enable the functions of gossip, e.g. advice-giving, feedback, support, and so on.
Worries about revealing an identifiable detail may, in many cases – or for many people – get in the way of gossiping. Rather than risk it, people may decide it’s better to say nothing at all, in which case they miss out on the potential benefits of talking about a difficult social situation or relationship that’s weighing on them. A rough benefit-risk analysis may help someone decide that the benefits of being open about their struggles outweigh the potential risks, especially when they’re making an effort to leave out non-essential personal details. However, in the moment, most people aren’t deliberating over what details to include and exclude, and in the flow of a conversation, more details may be disclosed than intended.
Hence, as in the case of certain implications of utilitarianism – where it’s considered morally obligatory or praiseworthy to donate large sums of money to charity – anonymised gossip may face a demandingness objection. To keep gossip truly anonymous may require a lot of care and worry. However, this demandingness is not really on the same level as the demands made by Singerian utilitarianism, for instance, where a large portion of our income and support must go to distant strangers, rather than relatives and loved ones. The stakes are also not as high; if we accidentally identify someone during gossip, we may disrespect them or affect someone’s impression of them, but their life isn’t on the line.
How Would the Gossipee Feel About Anonymised Gossip?
The exclusion-based view may help us think more clearly about the morality of anonymised gossip. According to this view, defended by Ali Raza Jatoi, gossip is often wrong because it excludes people who have a stake in being included in the conversation. They are locked out of a conversation they would want to be part of, so they can defend themselves.
If gossip is reasonably anonymised – that is, someone has made a sincere effort to keep identifiable information out of the conversation – would the gossipee still want to be included in that conversation? What interest would they have in being included? Realistically, if they did want to be included, to defend the unidentified person, and they did so passionately, this could give a clue that they are the person being talked about. This would therefore mean they have an interest in being excluded. On the other hand, they may want to be included to defend their perspective or actions, which they feel the gossiper is failing to represent.
If the gossipee is empathetic about the needs of the gossiper in getting emotional baggage off their chest, they may feel that the reasonable steps the gossiper has taken to anonymise them are a fair compromise. What is ‘reasonable’ may be subjective, and it’s often contextual; it depends on who is listening and their relationship (if any) to the gossipee. So, putting ourselves in the gossipee’s shoes also means imagining how they would feel about the context in which their information is being shared.
Anonymised Gossip is Not Always Moral
Truly anonymised gossip does not, however, make it intrinsically moral. Someone could gossip about someone without identifying them, but still be dishonest about the situation they’re describing. They could lie, leave out key details, over-emphasise their clean conscience, or project an image of moral superiority. In this way, the gossiper may get to enjoy an unearned positive reputation, even if the gossipee faces no negative consequences. Thus, anonymised gossip can still be unfair and unjustified; keeping names and other identifiable information out of the conversation is not sufficient to gossip well. On an exclusion-based account, the gossipee would likely still have an interest in the situation and their side of the story being fairly described.
Yet this raises the question of whether it’s morally wrong for someone to paint an overly negative picture of the gossipee if no negative consequences ever come their way as a result. On a non-consequentialist account, it could still be deemed wrong: on Kantian grounds, the gossiper is lying (and therefore violating a moral duty not to lie), while from the perspective of virtue ethics, the gossiper is cultivating the vice of dishonesty and becoming a dishonest person. From a Buddhist standpoint, anonymised gossip can still fan the flames of the gossiper’s anger, resentment, spite, hatred, and vengefulness. It may feed their ego, which is considered ‘unskillful’, even if the gossipee isn’t negatively affected. Cultivating these unskillful attitudes and tendencies may, however, make it more likely that the gossiper will cause harm to others at some other point.
Thinking about anonymity in gossip is merely one aspect of virtuous speech: sometimes it’s called for, sometimes not – and even when it’s called for, it’s not enough to make the gossip permissible. The permissibility or impermissibility of gossip comes in degrees, depending on the risks and benefits involved, or what’s at stake. By considering the potential role of anonymity in gossip, we’re at the very least paying closer attention to the interests of the absent person being talked about. And this kind of concern and habit makes us more thoughtful about the effects our speech can have.